Best Bakery and Cake Shops in North Captiva Island

"If you are a coffee addict, Coffee Bar at Bailey's General Store has been meeting the needs of everyone on Sanibel Island for over a century. Apart from the 37 varieties of coffee and smoothie beverages like an iced caramel latte or a tasty berry smoothie, they have an extensive takeaway counter of hot foods for breakfast as well. But our favorite reason to go to Baileys for a Sanibel island breakfast?"

"Finally, Jerry’s Foods is your one-stop-shop not only for ice cream but also for groceries, household items, and everything else you’ll need for a great stay on the island. If you’ve got a favorite national brand of ice cream that you usually pick up from your freezer section, you can find it right here and take it back to your rental!. You can also stock your kitchen with selections from their Fish Market, Butcher Shop, full-service deli, and Bake Shop."

"Say hello to the macaws on the porch as you head in to pick up some essentials at Jerry’s Foods. Jerry’s started as a butcher shop, so this is probably the best place to pick up some items for a cookout night at your condo. Also on your menu should be the Key lime pie, reported to be the best in the world — but I think there are several other destinations on Sanibel that might dispute that claim!"

"For some truly delicious and unique coffee-style beverages, we suggest taking a stroll to Sanibel Bean. They have a relaxing atmosphere to enjoy your beverage and are near many quaint little shops and boutiques. They have an extensive menu of delicious drinks to choose from and many café style treats and sammies!"

"Open Sunday - Thursday 7:00am to 2:00pm, Friday - Saturday 7:00am to 3:00pm. If it’s a quick cup-a-Joe to go or coffee drink and pastry you’re after, the Sanibel Bean is the best stop on Sanibel Island. They also serve breakfast all day."

"The Sanibel Bean has a dedicated following and is located across from the public park. It is self-service and has indoor and outside seating."

"I have never waited so long in a dunkin donuts and they never had someone working front of the house and everyone working drive threw bc they are so unde..."

"The Speckled Egg is located nearby McGregor Café but spews a unique menu. The Speckled Egg has a walk-up counter where you can place your order."

"Gulf Coast Fudge is handmade the old-fashion way from small batches of the finest ingredient. It's slow-cooked in a copper kettle using an original recipe that dates back to the 1800s. It is hand-poured and cooled on a marble slab table before being whipped into a loaf and individually sliced right before the eyes at the Shell Factory & Nature Park location."

"To start your day off right, or to keep your day at its best, head to Geppetto's Beach Foodies. Geppetto's is a homemade bakery owned by Donna and Tom Puma, who opened up the bakery in 2012. The shop offers pastries from places around the world such as New York, Tuscany, and Paris."