Best Dessert in Fort Myers Beach

"Joey’s Custard is not only a coffee shop but it’s also a place where you and your family can head to get a nice cold treat on a hot day. Located at 2467 Periwinkle Way in Sanibel you will find Joey’s Custard that is open 7 days a week from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm. They do offer their customers both indoor and outdoor seating so you too can enjoy the sunshine and the air conditioning on those hot days."

"With recipes handed down through the generations, long before its founding in 1952, the Farmers Market Restaurant is the oldest operating restaurant in the county. Old-fashioned breakfast favorites include farm-fresh omelettes alongside traditional southern dinner staples such as fried chicken gizzards, creamy shrimp and grits, and country fried steak. You’ll find the fried green tomato and bacon club sandwich for lunch just as warm and welcoming."

"The Farmer’s Market Restaurant is a great choice of those looking for a breakfast in Fort Myers that is served starting at 6 am every day expect Sunday. Breakfast hours here are 6:00 am until 10:30 am Monday through Saturday. Farmer’s Market Restaurant is one of the longest running restaurants in Fort Myers and serves up big portions of southern inspired food with recipes being passed down generations since opening in the 1960’s."

"The Farmers Market Restaurant is a local treasure just on the outskirts of downtown. This restaurant has been established for over 65 years serving home-cooked southern meals to the community. Serving familiar southern staples, you will not leave hungry."

"Jerry’s Café is open seven days a week for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy fresh-made breakfast pastries, signature sandwiches (check out our grouper!), delicious dinner entrees, and fabulous desserts – like our fan-favorite Key Lime Pie – all while enjoying our tropical bird habitat. In addition to our full menu we offer a build-your-own gourmet salad and sandwich bar, exciting daily specials, a fantastic full menu, and a wide assortment of beer and wine."

"Say hello to the macaws on the porch as you head in to pick up some essentials at Jerry’s Foods. Jerry’s started as a butcher shop, so this is probably the best place to pick up some items for a cookout night at your condo. Also on your menu should be the Key lime pie, reported to be the best in the world — but I think there are several other destinations on Sanibel that might dispute that claim!"

"Cold treats are a welcome indulgence on a hot day, and Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream has an assortment of cold treats available in a friendly and colorful environment. The homemade ice cream this long-standing establishment is known for comes in many unique flavors, including Sanibel Crunch and Dirty Sand Dollar. Other sweet treats that are available include gelato, frozen yogurt, sorbet, sherbet, pastries, and gluten-free cookies."

"Source: Photo by Wikimedia Commons user Alessio Damato used under CC BY-SA 3.0. Photo is only for illustrative purposes. For a cold, sweet treat on a hot afternoon, be sure to check out Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream."

"The Pinocchios Sanibel Store is an island vacation destination. Many say Pinocchios is the first place they come to on the island when they arrive and the last place they visit before hea..."

"My first time and everything I got was perfect, the wait time was quick, we only waited at most 5 minut..."

"Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack - Ready for Pick-Up Now"

"Gulf Coast Fudge is handmade the old-fashion way from small batches of the finest ingredient. It's slow-cooked in a copper kettle using an original recipe that dates back to the 1800s. It is hand-poured and cooled on a marble slab table before being whipped into a loaf and individually sliced right before the eyes at the Shell Factory & Nature Park location."

"Stopped by here before heading to the airport since my home state doesn't have a Krispy Kreme. It was a little after 4 AM so things were a little sl..."

"Directly from Italy, COLLEONI'S is a family operated Restaurant and Bakery featuring delicious Italian cuisine, friendly service and warm hospitality. We serve only authentic Italian food cooked in the Italian style, with fresh ingredients, with passion and love."

"This is the beach at the farthest west end of Sanibel Island, just before the bridge to Captiva Island. Blind Pass Beach is on the Sanibel side and Turner Beach is on the Captiva side. Keep in mind that both beaches have limited parking, and you cannot use your Sanibel beach parking receipt on Captiva beaches."

"Bunche Beach is located on the stunning San Carlos Bay, and it is one of the best beaches in Fort Myers. You can enjoy all of the usual beach activities there, including swimming, suntanning, and shelling. Quite a few starfish and crabs have made their home at Bunch Beach and let’s talk about shelling."

"We’re starting off the list with one of the coolest beaches in southwest Florida. And since it’s not technically on Fort Myers Beach, it’s probably the best Fort Myers sunset you will find!. We had to add it to our list because of its unique location in San Carlos between Ft."

"A beautiful beach with stunning white sands, Gulfside City Park offers both grassy and sandy areas for visitors to spend some time and listen to the waves. This beach, despite being located on a highly popular touristic island, never gets too crowded, so it's a nice spot to visit if you're looking for a little peace and quiet. Restrooms and showers can be found here, and there are also picnic areas and even grills open for public use, so it's a super spot to visit on a sunny weekend or special occasion."

"This 27-acre mid-island Park located on Algiers Lane off of Casa Ybel Road goes by two names, Gulfside City Park and also Algiers Beach after the road it’s on. It’s a quiet, pet-friendly beach park with plenty of space for kids to run around and pets to play, but it’s also one of our favorite beaches on Sanibel for sunbathing because of its private feel. Algiers Beach is perfect for dog-lovers!"

"Gulfside City Park Beach – known as Algiers Beach to locals – offers a prime spot for picnics under shade trees. Access the beach from boardwalks, and explore the nature trail to see native plants and wildlife. Families also enjoy shelling, dolphin-watching and grilling their favorite foods for lunch or an early dinner."

"Traders set their standard high for great food, an appealing environment and professional service. The casual atmosphere coupled with gourmet food has made this a popular destination for both locals and tourists. Enjoy dining on everything from raw oysters to veal meatloaf in this large, industrial space that's not only filled with food, but also eclectic shopping."