Best Dessert in Sanibel Island

"If looking for classic ice cream or soft serve check out Joey’s Custard. My nephew and I took a visit to here and I loved this quaint shop next to Bailey’s General Store."

"A family and veteran owned local business serving up premium Custards, Ice creams, Frozen-Yogurts, Sorbets, Italian Ices, coffee, espressos, and more!"

"If your sweet tooth says indulge, there is no better place than Joey’s Custard to satisfy your need for gourmet ice creams, yogurts and custards."

"With recipes handed down through the generations, long before its founding in 1952, the Farmers Market Restaurant is the oldest operating restaurant in the county. Old-fashioned breakfast favorites include farm-fresh omelettes alongside traditional southern dinner staples such as fried chicken gizzards, creamy shrimp and grits, and country fried steak. You’ll find the fried green tomato and bacon club sandwich for lunch just as warm and welcoming."

"Farmers Market Restaurant is one of the longest running and best restaurants in For Myers. Opened in 1952 Farmers market has been serving home cooked comfort food with recipes that have been passed down several generations. Each meal is served in big portions and great quality since opening!"

"The Farmers Market Restaurant is a local treasure just on the outskirts of downtown. This restaurant has been established for over 65 years serving home-cooked southern meals to the community. Serving familiar southern staples, you will not leave hungry."

"Jerry’s Café is open seven days a week for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy fresh-made breakfast pastries, signature sandwiches (check out our grouper!), delicious dinner entrees, and fabulous desserts – like our fan-favorite Key Lime Pie – all while enjoying our tropical bird habitat. In addition to our full menu we offer a build-your-own gourmet salad and sandwich bar, exciting daily specials, a fantastic full menu, and a wide assortment of beer and wine."

"Finally, Jerry’s Foods is your one-stop-shop not only for ice cream but also for groceries, household items, and everything else you’ll need for a great stay on the island. If you’ve got a favorite national brand of ice cream that you usually pick up from your freezer section, you can find it right here and take it back to your rental!. You can also stock your kitchen with selections from their Fish Market, Butcher Shop, full-service deli, and Bake Shop."

"Say hello to the macaws on the porch as you head in to pick up some essentials at Jerry’s Foods. Jerry’s started as a butcher shop, so this is probably the best place to pick up some items for a cookout night at your condo. Also on your menu should be the Key lime pie, reported to be the best in the world — but I think there are several other destinations on Sanibel that might dispute that claim!"

"Cold treats are a welcome indulgence on a hot day, and Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream has an assortment of cold treats available in a friendly and colorful environment. The homemade ice cream this long-standing establishment is known for comes in many unique flavors, including Sanibel Crunch and Dirty Sand Dollar. Other sweet treats that are available include gelato, frozen yogurt, sorbet, sherbet, pastries, and gluten-free cookies."

"Source: Photo by Wikimedia Commons user Alessio Damato used under CC BY-SA 3.0. Photo is only for illustrative purposes. For a cold, sweet treat on a hot afternoon, be sure to check out Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream."

"The Pinocchios Sanibel Store is an island vacation destination. Many say Pinocchios is the first place they come to on the island when they arrive and the last place they visit before hea..."

"My first time and everything I got was perfect, the wait time was quick, we only waited at most 5 minut..."

"Gulf Coast Fudge is handmade the old-fashion way from small batches of the finest ingredient. It's slow-cooked in a copper kettle using an original recipe that dates back to the 1800s. It is hand-poured and cooled on a marble slab table before being whipped into a loaf and individually sliced right before the eyes at the Shell Factory & Nature Park location."

"Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack - Ready for Pick-Up Now"

"Stopped by here before heading to the airport since my home state doesn't have a Krispy Kreme. It was a little after 4 AM so things were a little sl..."

"Old Soul Brewing is a family owned craft beer brewery in Fort Myers, Florida. Come check out our relaxing atmosphere and handcrafted ales!"

"I have been frequenting fort myers for the last 3 or 4 years and ALWAYS make sure I stop here to get something to eat. The owners treat you like…"

"For a larger brewery experience, complete with guided tours, Fort Myers Brewing Company is an awesome option. You can book a tour for Wednesday or Saturday, or stop by the taproom to try one of their 25+ beers on tap!. We had found their High 5 IPA and American Wheat in stores before and were intrigued to try more."

"We have over 25 beers on tap plus at least one food truck onsite every day!. Our trucks rotate, so visit our website or give us call to find out who’s on-site. Want to bring your own food, that’s fine too!"

"Like the Cypress Slough Preserve, the Four Mile Cove Ecological Preserve in Cape Coral has a wonderful boardwalk through the Florida wetlands with plenty of photo ops. Plus, this preserve is attached to the Veterans Memorial Park, which features many impressive war monuments. The Four Mile Cove Ecological Preserve is open between 8 AM till dusk on most days."

"This beautiful 3500 acre wetland park is home to a plethora of amazing creatures including turtles, otters, alligators, birds, and more. At Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve, you can walk along a boardwalk to get a close look at the wetlands or visit the interpretive center to learn more about the flora and fauna that live there. It is a great place to visit before heading to the Everglades if you want to develop a decent base of knowledge about what you will be seeing."

"Measuring roughly 3,500 acres, the Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve has a fantastic 1.2-mile boardwalk through the Florida wetlands. Nature lovers will really enjoy taking a few selfies at this preserve’s many lookout points. This preserve is usually open between dawn and dusk every day, but always check the Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve’s website for info on closures."

"The Clam Shack is an uncompromising celebration of all things seafood. You get a lovely and quaint environment to dine on seafood of every shape and size. There’s a wide selection of seafood sandwiches, including lobster, clams, tuna, haddock, and more."

" restaurant going down the tubes I gave them a couple of stars because my son enjoyed his hotdog and fries.”more. Indoor & Outdoor dining"

"The hostess was great and worked with us to seat our part of 9... even texted to give us updates. The fish & chips were light..."

"Quick and Not Busy Drive Through, woman who was at the window seemed confused, but friendly, outdated look, dine in was not open."