Discover the best deals from millions of vacation homes

Here at VacationHomeRents, you can easily find and compare the best vacation apartments, cabins, house boats, beach houses, and RV deals. By a simple click, we help you search among millions of listings across the top sites like Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com and more.
Airbnb Fire Island, NYVrbo Fire Island, NYBooking.com Fire Island, NYOutdoorsy Fire Island, NYRvshare.com Fire Island, NY
And more...

Find the best vacation rental

ACCOMMODATION TYPES

Save Up To 81%

Airbnb, Vacation rentals and hotel deals in Fire Island, NY

The Ocean Bay House
4.9 (172 reviews)
The Ocean Bay House
Inn · 1 Bedroom
$360 /night
View deal
Dog-Friendly Condo with High-Speed WiFi, Outdoor Shower, Gas Grill, Beach Access
3.0 (3 reviews)
Dog-Friendly Condo with High-Speed WiFi, Outdoor Shower, Gas Grill, Beach Access
Condo · 4 Guests · 2 Bedrooms
$255 /night*
View deal
The Palms Hotel Fire Island
3.7 (202 reviews)
The Palms Hotel Fire Island
Hotel · 1 Bedroom
$480 /night
View deal
3 Bedroom,1Bath, WIFI, Kitchen, DW, Micro,Laundry Fac,Gas BBQ, SatTV,Large Deck
4.2 (66 reviews)
3 Bedroom,1Bath, WIFI, Kitchen, DW, Micro,Laundry Fac,Gas BBQ, SatTV,Large Deck
Holiday home · 6 Guests · 3 Bedrooms
$400 /night*
View deal
Dog-Friendly Home w/ Fast WiFi, Washer/Dryer, & Private Grill - Close to Beach!
Dog-Friendly Home w/ Fast WiFi, Washer/Dryer, & Private Grill - Close to Beach!
Holiday home · 8 Guests · 4 Bedrooms
$450 /night*
View deal
Ocean Bay Park - Booking Now 2022!
4.9 (41 reviews)
Ocean Bay Park - Booking Now 2022!
Holiday home · 10 Guests · 5 Bedrooms
$500 /night*
View deal
Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street
5.0 (1 review)
Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street
Hotel · 1 Bedroom
$260 /night
View deal
Beach Cottage on Fire Island
Beach Cottage on Fire Island
Cottage · 8 Guests · 4 Bedrooms
$350 /night*
View deal
Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Sleeps 3 max, Credit Cards Accepted
3.1 (9 reviews)
Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Sleeps 3 max, Credit Cards Accepted
Apartment · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$267 /night*
View deal

Airbnb, Holiday Beachfront House with Air Conditioning in Fire Island, NY

Classic 5BR Bay Front Beach Cottage-BAY & SUNSET VIEWS! PRIVATE! DISINFECTED!
Air Conditioning
4.7 (18 reviews)
Classic 5BR Bay Front Beach Cottage-BAY & SUNSET VIEWS! PRIVATE! DISINFECTED!
Cottage · 10 Guests · 5 Bedrooms
$750 /night*
View deal
🌞New Listing!! Ocean View Retreat!🌞
Air Conditioning
4.8 (11 reviews)
🌞New Listing!! Ocean View Retreat!🌞
Holiday home · 4 Guests · 2 Bedrooms
$550 /night*
View deal
Fire Island Beach House (Atlantique)
Air Conditioning
5.0 (6 reviews)
Fire Island Beach House (Atlantique)
Holiday home · 8 Guests · 4 Bedrooms
$600 /night*
View deal

Airbnb, Holiday Beachfront House with Full Kitchen, and Other Rental Options in Fire Island, NY

FAIR HARBOR, FIRE ISLAND!! 3 Min Walk To The Beach. SLEEPS 10.
Full Kitchen
4.6 (13 reviews)
FAIR HARBOR, FIRE ISLAND!! 3 Min Walk To The Beach. SLEEPS 10.
Holiday home · 8 Guests · 4 Bedrooms
$600 /night*
View deal
Fire Island Beach House (Atlantique)
Full Kitchen
5.0 (6 reviews)
Fire Island Beach House (Atlantique)
Holiday home · 8 Guests · 4 Bedrooms
$600 /night*
View deal
Ocean Beach/Corneille Est, Fire Island Beach House
Full Kitchen
5.0 (7 reviews)
Ocean Beach/Corneille Est, Fire Island Beach House
Holiday home · 10 Guests · 5 Bedrooms
$799 /night*
View deal

Airbnb, Pet Friendly Vacation Cottage in Fire Island, NY

Classic 5BR Bay Front Beach Cottage-BAY & SUNSET VIEWS! PRIVATE! DISINFECTED!
Pets Welcome
4.7 (18 reviews)
Classic 5BR Bay Front Beach Cottage-BAY & SUNSET VIEWS! PRIVATE! DISINFECTED!
Cottage · 10 Guests · 5 Bedrooms
$750 /night*
View deal
Beach Cottage on Fire Island
Pets Welcome
Beach Cottage on Fire Island
Cottage · 8 Guests · 4 Bedrooms
$350 /night*
View deal
THE LEGENDARY PYRAMID HOUSE
Pets Welcome
5.0 (4 reviews)
THE LEGENDARY PYRAMID HOUSE
Cabin · 6 Guests · 3 Bedrooms
$1,500 /night*
View deal

Airbnb, Vacation Cottage with Fireplace in Fire Island, NY

THE LEGENDARY PYRAMID HOUSE
Fireplace
5.0 (4 reviews)
THE LEGENDARY PYRAMID HOUSE
Cabin · 6 Guests · 3 Bedrooms
$1,500 /night*
View deal

How Does The Amenity Info Looks Like at Fire Island, NY?

Best Amenities in Fire Island, NY

Above shows the popular amenities in Fire Island and the number of the rental properties associated with each amenity. In Fire Island, 714 rentals offer Internet or Wifi, 673 rentals offer No Smoking, 635 rentals offer Air Conditioning. So, if you need Internet or Wifi during your vacation, use the Internet or Wifi filter to compare these properties. Two amenities that are not typical are Hot Tub, Pool.

Which Price Range Is Considered As A Good Deal in Fire Island, NY Area?

Vacation House & Apartment Rental Price Information in Fire Island, NY

The graph shows the percentages of vacation homes in each price bucket. Fire Island has the largest percentage (43.08%) of homes in $500+ price range.
$0 to 50
$0 to 50
$50 to 100
$50 to 100
$100 to 150
$100 to 150
$150 to 200
$150 to 200
$200 to 250
$200 to 250
$250 to 300
$250 to 300
$300 to 350
$300 to 350
$350 to 400
$350 to 400
$400 to 450
$400 to 450
$450 to 500
$450 to 500
$500 +
$500 +
Which Accommodations Should I Pick in Fire Island, NY?
Most Picked Accommodations in Fire Island, NY
Before visiting Fire Island, it is a good idea to explore all the accommodation types in this area, and pick the one that fits your group well. All the available accommodation types are: House, Apartment, Studio, Cottage, Condo, Hotel, Townhome, Bungalow, Villa, Estate, Bed And Breakfast, Caravan, Guest House, Boat, Mobile Home, Cabin, Yacht, Chateau / Country House, Castle. House is the most-liked rental type, with the largest percentage of 74.13%. The biggest home in this area available for rent is around 12000 square feet.The least popular accommodation in Fire Island is Chateau / Country House rentals
How Many Accommodations Are Pets Allowed in Fire Island, NY?
Pets Allowed vs Not Allowed in Fire Island, NY
25.36% of vacation homes in Fire Island are pet friendly. Either you bring your loved pets on vacation or you have pet allergies, make sure to select the homes by applying the right filters.
Which Airports Should I Choose To Get To Fire Island, NY?
Airports Options in Fire Island, NY
* The displayed nightly rate may be estimated based on a future travel date. Narrow down your search with checkin and checkout dates to see the exact price.
See all offers