Best Gelato in Sanibel Island

"We go to Sanibel Deli for a great sub and deli sandwich but they also have amazing coffee and baked goods."

"If you're one of those people, Pinocchio's Ice Cream will satisfy you on your first bite. This homemade ice cream shop serves over 130 impressive flavors, including Dirty Sand Dollar, Couch Potato, and Flying Pig. Pinocchio's is the other half of Geppetto's Beach Foodies, and the two stores are connected on the inside to allow for easy access to an array of sweet treats."

"The name of this establishment pretty much sums up what you can expect!. Sanibel’s Best Homemade Ice Cream is among the best family friendly things to do in the area thanks to their welcoming atmosphere and virtually endless flavor options. Every flavor is made with the highest quality ingredients, giving you a perfect taste every time."

"If looking for classic ice cream or soft serve check out Joey’s Custard. My nephew and I took a visit to here and I loved this quaint shop next to Bailey’s General Store."

"A family and veteran owned local business serving up premium Custards, Ice creams, Frozen-Yogurts, Sorbets, Italian Ices, coffee, espressos, and more!"

"If your sweet tooth says indulge, there is no better place than Joey’s Custard to satisfy your need for gourmet ice creams, yogurts and custards."

"What’s not to love about an old-timey place that serves burgers, hot dogs, crispy fries, and milkshakes?. There isn’t any inside seating, but there are plenty of outdoor tables and Schnapper’s was also voted best take out on the island. Pro tip: Grab your burger and milkshake and take it to the beach with you!"

"For some truly delicious and unique coffee-style beverages, we suggest taking a stroll to Sanibel Bean. They have a relaxing atmosphere to enjoy your beverage and are near many quaint little shops and boutiques. They have an extensive menu of delicious drinks to choose from and many café style treats and sammies!"

"Open Sunday - Thursday 7:00am to 2:00pm, Friday - Saturday 7:00am to 3:00pm. If it’s a quick cup-a-Joe to go or coffee drink and pastry you’re after, the Sanibel Bean is the best stop on Sanibel Island. They also serve breakfast all day."

"Popular local hangout with an extensive cafe menu of quick, cheap eats that are surprisingly tasty and prepared with love. The staff are as friendly as they come."

"Enjoying ice cream as it melts onto your hand is a beach vacation rite of passage. Royal Scoop has been delivering happiness to their customers since 1979. The service alone at Royal Scoop is enough reason to visit this favorite, but their ice cream is delicious as well."

"Cold treats are a welcome indulgence on a hot day, and Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream has an assortment of cold treats available in a friendly and colorful environment. The homemade ice cream this long-standing establishment is known for comes in many unique flavors, including Sanibel Crunch and Dirty Sand Dollar. Other sweet treats that are available include gelato, frozen yogurt, sorbet, sherbet, pastries, and gluten-free cookies."

"Source: Photo by Wikimedia Commons user Alessio Damato used under CC BY-SA 3.0. Photo is only for illustrative purposes. For a cold, sweet treat on a hot afternoon, be sure to check out Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream."

"The Pinocchios Sanibel Store is an island vacation destination. Many say Pinocchios is the first place they come to on the island when they arrive and the last place they visit before hea..."

"We had two terrific meals at Rosie's during our recent stay on Sanibel. We initially tried it when the restaurant we had planned to go to had a lon..."

"Gulf Coast Fudge is handmade the old-fashion way from small batches of the finest ingredient. It's slow-cooked in a copper kettle using an original recipe that dates back to the 1800s. It is hand-poured and cooled on a marble slab table before being whipped into a loaf and individually sliced right before the eyes at the Shell Factory & Nature Park location."

"If you are looking for a place to go with a relaxing atmosphere to work, read, or perhaps even meet someone, then Bailey’s Coffee Bar is where you want to be. They have a large menu for the coffee addicts and a delicious café style menu if you are looking for a treat or lighter fare. They have various beverages to choose from, including hot and iced espressos, hot chocolates, smoothies, and other refreshing drinks you would expect on the island!"

"Normally I wouldn’t think of a grocery store for grabbing a cup of coffee but the coffee shop, The Coffee Bar By Bailey, in the Bailey’s grocery and general store will always hit the spot. They have tons of different options, of a basic brew, cappuccinos and iced coffees as well."

"You don’t need to have drunk a cannabidiol-infused beverage to have a relaxing experience at the Seed & Bean Market. That said, this cannabis-friendly cafe is certainly one of the most chilled spots in Fort Myers. Order yourself a portion of beef tips with hemp hearts, zesty lobster pasta, or the excellent grilled cheese with bacon cannabis beer jam, and feel your hunger ebb away, along with your cares."

"While exploring the downtown area of Fort Myers, be sure to stop by their beautiful mini-market and coffee shop. They provide guests with a variety of CBD-infused beverages and a delightful array of dining options. Address: 1520 Broadway #107, Fort Myers, FL 33901 | Phone:(239) 243-8137"

"For some truly delicious and unique coffee-style beverages, we suggest taking a stroll to Sanibel Bean. They have a relaxing atmosphere to enjoy your beverage and are near many quaint little shops and boutiques. They have an extensive menu of delicious drinks to choose from and many café style treats and sammies!"

"Open Sunday - Thursday 7:00am to 2:00pm, Friday - Saturday 7:00am to 3:00pm. If it’s a quick cup-a-Joe to go or coffee drink and pastry you’re after, the Sanibel Bean is the best stop on Sanibel Island. They also serve breakfast all day."

"Popular local hangout with an extensive cafe menu of quick, cheap eats that are surprisingly tasty and prepared with love. The staff are as friendly as they come."